India’s Modi comes to Russia - with love.
Dr. Sreeram Chaulia, RT
23 Dec, 2015 10:12
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s first state visit to Russia on December 23-24 promises to unlock new vistas of cooperation for energizing an age-old strategic partnership at a time when both nations need each other more than ever.
Although annual Russia-India summits were institutionalized long ago and this is the sixteenth edition, the assertive push being given by Modi and President Vladimir Putin to re-script ties by breaking fresh ground makes this week’s dialogue special.
Redressing imbalances and shortcomings
The main lacuna currently holding back the full potential of the Russia-India relationship is an underwhelming performance in the economic sphere, which has lagged despite political will and pledges in both Moscow and New Delhi to ramp them up.
With bilateral trade stuck at a meager $10 billion per annum and two-way cumulative foreign investment flows lingering at just $12 billion, neither side can afford to allow the business-to-business links to drift to such a point that there is no longer a deeper beneficial exchange between two societies that had historically been closely knit.
In the contemporary period of economic interdependence and maximization of profit-making via diplomacy, the Russia-India affair is top-heavy with robust military-to-military deals among state elites but shaky at the bottom where civilian commerce is not booming.
Conscious of the need to broad-base the glue that holds these two all-weather friends together, Modi has mobilized a galaxy of Indian industry stalwarts to accompany him and attend the India-Russia CEO Summit. The high-profile makeup of the Indian business delegation in Moscow sends a message that Modi recognizes the true economic worth of Russia despite the fact that it is passing through a difficult downturn amidst plunging oil and gas prices. It should also help clear mutual misconceptions about inhospitable conditions for doing business in both countries.
Wooing Russian investors and entrepreneurs
For all the portrayals of Russia as struggling under the weight of Western sanctions, Modi senses a major opening in attracting Russian investors to India’s National Infrastructure Fund. Russia is flush with big-pocketed billionaires who are not facing a welcoming environment in their traditional European financial havens due to Putin’s resistance to Western geopolitical agendas.
With Putin’s facilitation, Modi would like to tap into these vast reservoirs of financing for the ‘Make in India’ campaign— an ambitious plan to build a strong indigenous manufacturing base which can generate employment and export revenues.
Even though Western stereotyping has painted Russia as technologically backward, it boasts of advanced aerospace, nanotechnology, metallurgy, optics and software sectors that Modi is aiming to connect with India’s economic growth story by setting up a $3 billion joint innovation fund.
But the enterprising genius of Russian youth, who have taken to start-ups in information technology, is close to Modi’s own ‘Startup India’ blueprint, and therefore he would want to forge conversations between the two for a nice opportunity at cross-learning.
Western sanctions: India’s opening
Owing to the retaliatory trade embargoes between the European Union and Russia, India is poised to step in and meet Russia’s demand for dairy products, seafood etc. The Russian Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Rogozin sees Indian manufacturers as “a big partner that can fill the vacuum” caused by Russia’s standoff with the West and its allies like Turkey. Modi is alert to this dynamic and is pressing on all cylinders for a commercial liftoff that has sadly evaded Russia and India.
This process will also be boosted by China’s own economic slowdown, which signals that Russia cannot place all its eggs in Beijing’s basket to lift its chestnuts out of the fire. As a faster growing country than China, which does not pose any strategic threat whatsoever to Russia, India could be Russia’s white knight.
The reverse also holds true in the context of the quest for civilian nuclear energy in India, which rests very much on upgraded Russian assistance. Russia has faithfully stood by India no matter how hesitant and slow Western atomic energy companies have become about civilian nuclear commerce.
During the latest summit, Modi and Putin will be signing agreements for two new Russian-backed nuclear plants in the southern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh in accord with the localization norms of the ‘Make in India’ program.
Next generation defense cooperation

Modi is visiting Moscow after wrapping up a series of big-ticket agreements for new defense sector collaboration, including Russia’s state-of-the-art S-400 anti-aircraft missile system worth $4.5 billion.
Military purchases have been the mainstays of the bilateral relationship, but India has diversified its suppliers and made its market more competitive for foreign bidders. To regain its share of the Indian defense pie, Russia has gone farthest in co-production and transfer of know-how.
In the words of the Russian Ambassador to India, Alexander Kadakin, “no country in the world shares with India the most secret and confidential things that it possesses.” Hence the noteworthy decision by Russia to jointly manufacture 200 light helicopters with local Indian partners for deployment with the Indian military, and eventually the Russian armed forces and possibly other buyers.
The model of the world’s fastest Brahmos supersonic cruise missile— offspring of the marriage of Indian and Russian defense companies— which is being sought by Southeast Asian and Latin American countries, reveals that the Russia-India bilateral synergy can deliver world-class results.
If the two countries also move forward in implementing a joint venture to build a fifth generation stealth fighter aircraft, it would set benchmarks and reify Modi’s vision of the defense industry attaining a central place in the ‘Make in India’ initiative.
The remark by Modi’s industrialization czar, Amitabh Kant, that “whatever we do with Russia will have a 'Make-in-India' component,” and Russia’s readiness to play ball for both pecuniary and strategic reasons, mean that the future of the Russia-India partnership is bright.
Reviving people-to-people ties
When Modi met Putin in Ufa earlier in 2015, he expressed admiration and pride at the manner in which the Russian people took to celebrating his trademark International Yoga Day. Modi is keen to see many more centers of Yoga emerge in Russia and help the Russian people rediscover India’s ancient wisdom. His government is also enthused by the scholarship of Russian Indologists, whose translations of Indian epics into Russian enhances India’s soft power.
What has been missing, though, is more intense cultural diplomacy by Russia in Indian society. The exposure of Indian people to Russian movies, art, music, ballet and literature has declined since the heydays of the Soviet Union. It must be revived to rekindle the soft spot that older Indians always had for all things Russian, and which has faded now with the younger generation.
Affirming Putin’s value
For a leader pigeonholed as ‘pro-American’ by those who have misread his core ‘India first’ nationalism, Modi appreciates Putin as an indispensable problem-solver for countering extremism and working to end armed conflicts in Syria and Ukraine. He sees no reason to buy into the ‘ostracize Putin’ motto of the West and is preparing to sign an extensive counter-terrorism pact in Moscow, living up to Rogozin’s billing of our two countries as the “vanguard of the struggle” against Islamist fundamentalism.
To India, Putin is a trustworthy and influential figure who holds the cards to a more stable and peaceful world. Modi’s praise of Putin’s “substantial views and a very clear and frank position as a permanent member of the UN Security Council” leaves no ambiguity that wherever Indian and Russian interests converge, they will work in tandem in pursuit of the shared vision of a multipolar international order.
Putin’s proactive role as a kingmaker and deal-broker in global crises has already neutralized Western designs of isolating Russia. In Moscow this week, Modi is reconfirming that Russia is indeed “our country’s greatest friend” and reminding the international community that Putin is too important to be spurned.
----------------
‘Where does India fit in the new Russia-China partnership?’
RT.com
24 Dec, 2015 12:27
It is important for India to remain part of the conversation with Russia and China despite disagreements between Beijing and New Delhi over Afghanistan and Pakistan, Indian journalist and commentator Vijay Prashad told RT.
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrived to Moscow on Wednesday for a two-day visit, just one week after India’s Defense Acquisition Council (DAC) approved the purchase of five S-400 air defense systems from Russia.
RT: Why is Modi's visit so significant at this particular time?
Vijay Prashad: Mr. Modi has been traveling to most of the world’s capitals. So it was about time he came to Moscow. The most important aspect of this visit is that there needs to be a readjustment between India and Russia. This has been a long time coming, particularly given the fact that Russia and China have been creating a new kind of partnership. I think there needs to be a discussion of where India fits in to the new Russia- China partnership.
RT: It's believed the two countries will sign a massive weapon deal. How significant will this be for both Moscow and India's military goals?
VP: India used to buy most of its armaments from Russia, then the Soviet Union, until the 1990’s. From the 1990’s onward, India has diversified its purchases from the US and to a large extent from countries like Israel. It seems now that Russian arms have come back on line. India is going to rebalance some of its arms purchases. It is important to bear in mind: India is the leading importer of weapons in the world.
But actually there is something else on the horizon here, not merely arms purchases. India is now eager to create a domestic arms industry, and it seems that the Russian government is quite willing to transfer some technology towards this end. So not only will India likely begin to buy greater volumes of arms from Russia – there is talk of several billions of dollars of arms purchases in this two-day trip itself - but also India is going to try to ink some deals so that it can develop its own arms industry.
RT: How important do you think relations with Russia are for India?
VP: India has over the last 20 years leaned quite heavily towards the US. And in the last 10 years or so with the emergence of the BRICS bloc, this has balanced out India’s allegiances or alliances with the US. So the relationship with Russia is very important because it brings India back somehow not so much as a subordinate ally of the US, but it might allow India to develop once again a rational pragmatic foreign policy based on a more complicated understanding of the world. When the Indian government saw the geopolitics as largely framed by the US that had a tendency to move India into the Western camp. Now with the emergence of what we might consider multi-polarity, the new relationship with Russia will allow India at least to balance its place in the world order.
RT: China is also a diplomatic rival of India. How might Beijing view a potential deal between Russian and India?
VP: This is a very complicated situation. India and China have a great deal of disagreement about the role, for instance, of the Taliban in Afghanistan, where because of China’s entanglement with Pakistan, it has a slightly different view than the Indian government. This is also of course the case between, say, the role of the pipelines that are being drawn across Asia: what is the relationship between China and Pakistan; where will India fit into this?
...It is important that India remains part of the conversation. It is important that countries such as Russia and China understand that the enmity between India and Pakistan should not be used as a tool against these countries. But they should also use their leverage as a way to bring India and Pakistan to the same table.
----------------
Russia, India Sign Agreements Simplifying Mutual Travel.
WORLD 19:04 24.12.2015
Russia and India have signed a package of deals after talks between President Vladimir Putin and Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Thursday, including on simplifying travel for certain categories of citizens.
MOSCOW (Sputnik) – Among the signed agreements were a protocol amending the December 21, 2010, Russian-Indian agreement simplifying business and tourist visa approvals, and another protocol amending the December 3, 2004, mutual travel agreement for diplomatic and official passport holders.
Modi arrived in Moscow for a two-day visit to hold talks with Putin on a range of bilateral issues, including transport, trade, energy, and the economy.
----------------
Putin Reaffirms Close Military-Technical Cooperation With India.
WORLD 19:57 24.12.2015
Vladimir Putin said that Russia and India are maintaining close military-technical cooperation and have good prospects in joint development of a multi-role fighter and a multi-purpose transport plane.
MOSCOW (Sputnik) – Russia and India are maintaining close military-technical cooperation and have good prospects in joint development of a multi-role fighter and a multi-purpose transport plane, President Vladimir Putin said Thursday.
"Our countries traditionally maintain close cooperation in the military-technical sphere. It involves not only deliveries of ready-to-use products, but also a close technological cooperation," Putin said at a joint news conference with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi following talks in Moscow.
"We also note good prospects of talks on joint development of a multi-role fighter and a multi-purpose transport plane," Putin added.
----------------
Russia, India Agree to Boost Cooperation in Space Exploration.
WORLD 20:15 24.12.2015
Russia and India have affirmed common dedication to further collaborate in developing space exploration, rocket manufacture and engine manufacture, according to a joint statement published Thursday following talks between the two countries' leaders.
MOSCOW (Sputnik) – Earlier in the day, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi met with Russian President Vladimir Putin during his visit to Moscow.
The sides positively assessed the June 2015 Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) and Russian Federal Space Agency (Roscosmos).
The memorandum deals with developing cooperation in areas of mutual interest, including satellite navigation, human spaceflight program technologies and launch vehicle development. The memorandum is notable for being signed on the 40th anniversary of the launch of the first Indian satellite by a Soviet rocket, according to the statement.
Modi arrived in Moscow for a two-day annual summit on Wednesday to hold talks with Putin on a range of bilateral issues, including transport, trade, energy, and the economy.
----------------
Russia to ship 10mn tons of oil annually to India in next 10 years – Putin.
RT.com
24 Dec, 2015 20:54
Russia will supply India with 10 million tons of oil annually in the next 10 years, President Vladimir Putin said after meeting Indian PM Narendra Modi in Moscow. The two also agreed upon several major deals in defense, trade and nuclear energy.
“In the framework of the agreement between Rosneft and Esser group, large-scale supplies of oil and petroleum products – 10 million tons of oil annually in the next 10 years – are planned to be delivered to Indian refineries,” said Putin Thursday during a joint statement with Modi.
The Indian prime minister is on a two-day visit to Moscow as part of the 16th Annual Bilateral Summit. The summit started on Thursday with a private dinner hosted by Putin in the Kremlin following which Russia and India inked 15 agreements.
Moscow reiterated its commitment to cooperate in the nuclear sphere as Putin confirmed Russia’s plans to build at least six new nuclear power units in India in the next 20 years. In April, 2014 Russia and India agreed to begin phase two of the Kudankulam plant, which is to be launched in the coming weeks. According to Putin and Modi, the construction of Blocks 3 and 4 is to be launched shortly, while negotiations are still held on the construction of Blocks 5 and 6.
India and Russia reaffirmed that military-technical cooperation remains one of the key objectives of their partnership.
“It's not just about the final product, but about close technological cooperation,” Putin explained.
He elaborated that the two countries have been successfully cooperating in the production of BrahMos short-range supersonic missiles and that they planned to jointly develop a new type of jet fighter and transport aircraft.
Russia and India have also affirmed their commitment to further collaborate in developing space exploration, rocket manufacture and engine manufacture.
Modi and Putin inked documents simplifying the approval of business and tourist visas, while the PM urged Russian businesses to more actively invest in India.
"Russia is our most loyal partner, particularly in the fields of defense, security, that's why I've come [here] to welcome our partner to participate in our country's economic progress," Modi said. "Russia is holding a leading position in many spheres such as space, information technologies and heavy industry."
On Wednesday, Modi announced a large-scale development program for the country’s armed forces, which could be worth $150 billion. Earlier, India’s Deputy Foreign Affairs Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar promised to increase mutual investment five-fold over the next decade.
“Mutual investments currently average around $11 billion and we want to increase them to $30-50 billion by 2025,”Jaishankar told reporters on Tuesday. He called it a "very big priority" for both parties.
In joint statement on Thursday the Russian and Indian leaders also condemned terrorism saying that the fight against it is only possible if the entire global community joins efforts dropping “selectiveness and double standards.”
"It is important Russia and India make similar approaches to key international problems. Our countries are for a political settlement of the conflict in Syria and promotion of national reconciliation in Afghanistan," Putin said.
“Together with President Putin we have a great level of mutual understanding of global issues,” said Modi.

December 24, 2015. Russian President Vladimir Putin, left, and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi meet in the Kremlin. © Sergey Guneev / Sputnik
----------------
Putin, Modi Highly Estimate Results of Trade, Investment Cooperation.
POLITICS 17:14 26.12.2015
A mutual intention to further promote relations of especially privileged strategic partnership between India and Russia was confirmed on the meeting of Russian President Vladimir Putin and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, according to the statement of the Kremlin press service.
MOSCOW (Sputnik) — Russian President Vladimir Putin and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi praised the agreements on trade and investment reached by the countries and confirmed disposition for further development of bilateral relations during a phone call, the Kremlin press service said on Saturday.
Modi visited Moscow on December 23-24 and held talks with Putin.
"A high appraisal was given to the achieved results, to the agreements in trade and economic, investment, scientific, technological and humanitarian spheres. A mutual intention to further promote relations of especially privileged strategic partnership between India and Russia was confirmed," a statement reads.
The statement added that Modi thanked Putin for the hospitality extended during the official visit of the Indian prime minister to Moscow.